Context and Background
Following a series of appearances before the Senate and House of Representatives in respect of the 2026
Budget Proposals, the Honourable Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Mr.
Wale Edun, provided detailed explanations of the Federal Government’s fiscal position, including the
performance of the 2024 and 2025 budgets.
Public and media engagement has been robust and constructive. However, extensive review of media
coverage shows that some misunderstandings persist, largely arising from the technical structure of
Nigeria’s fiscal federal system and the distinction between Federation and Federal Government finances.
This brief clarifies those issues to support accurate reporting and informed public discourse, particularly
regarding:
• Revenue performance
• Capital expenditure execution
• Debt service trends
• Public debt growth
The Structural Break: What Fundamentally Changed Under President Bola Ahmed Tinubu
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s administration inherited a fiscal system burdened by structural
distortions that masked the true condition of public finances. Since 2023, reforms have not been
incremental — they represent a fundamental reset of Nigeria’s fiscal architecture.
Two reforms define this shift:
1. Ending the Illegal and Excessive Use of Ways and Means
Under previous fiscal practice, deficits, including payment to contractors and debt service payments,
were financed heavily through overdrafts from the Central Bank, known as Ways and Means Advances.
Over time:
• These advances accumulated to approximately ₦30 trillion.
• They were not transparently reflected in the fiscal deficit framework.
• They effectively amounted to monetary financing — expanding money supply without
corresponding revenue.
• They contributed to inflationary pressures and weakened macroeconomic credibility.
Under the current administration:
• Illegal and excessive recourse to Ways and Means has been halted.
• The ₦30 trillion has been securitized and formally recognized within the public debt framework.
• Deficits are now financed through transparent borrowing instruments subject to legislative
oversight.
Implication
Government can no longer “print money” to close fiscal gaps. Spending must now align with actual
revenue or properly structured borrowing.
This transition has tightened fiscal space in the short term — but it restores credibility, strengthens
macroeconomic stability, and protects long-term growth.
2. Full Fiscal Transparency
The second defining reform is transparency.
Previously:
• FX subsidies created implicit fiscal losses.
• Fuel subsidies were under-budgeted or not fully reflected.
• Ways and Means liabilities were outside formal debt reporting.
Today:
• Subsidies have been removed.
• Liabilities are transparently recorded.
• Revenues and expenditures reflect economic reality.
The result is a fiscal framework grounded in transparency rather than suppressed obligations.
Short-term strain is the price of long-term sustainability.
Key Misconceptions Observed in Public Discourse
1. Federation Revenue Is Not the Same as Federal Government Revenue
This is the most widespread misunderstanding.
Nigeria operates a three-tier federal system comprising:
• Federal Government
• 36 State Governments
• 774 Local Governments
Most nationally collected revenues are paid into the Federation Account and distributed monthly by the
Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC).
How Revenue Is Shared
Major revenue sources include:
• Oil and gas revenue
• Company Income Tax
• Customs duties
• Value Added Tax (VAT)
• Non-cash revenue items (e.g., TETFund)
• Other federally collected revenues
While the statutory sharing formula often cited publicly is:
• Federal Government – 52.68%
• States – 26.72%
• Local Governments – 20.60%
• Oil Producing States – 13% derivation (from oil revenue only and collected before the sharing
formular above).
This broad formula does not apply uniformly across all revenue types. Each revenue source has its
own allocation structure — and this is where misunderstanding arises.
Why Oil & Gas Shortfalls Hit the Federal Government Hardest
Oil and gas revenues have a higher proportional allocation to the Federal Government than many other
revenue sources.
• The Federal Government receives approximately 53–65% of oil and gas revenues (depending on
components).
• VAT, by contrast, is shared 20% to the Federal Government and 80% to States and Local
Governments.
Implication
If oil revenue underperforms:
• The Federal Government suffers a disproportionately larger shortfall.
• States and Local Governments are relatively less affected.
Case Study: 2024 and 2025 Oil Revenue Shortfalls
2025:
• Projected Oil & Gas Federation Revenue: ₦37.4 trillion
• Actual Inflow: ₦7 trillion (19% performance)
Had projections been realized:
• The Federal Government would have received roughly ₦15 trillion more.
Thus:
• Federation revenue can appear broadly stable in aggregate,
• Yet Federal Government revenue may fall significantly below target.
In 2024, State and Local Government revenue targets were broadly met at the Federation level, while the
Federal Government’s revenue target was not — primarily due to oil shortfalls. This distinction is critical
for accurate reporting.
Additional Clarification: NRS vs Budget Office Targets
The Nigeria Revenue Service (NRS) collects a large share of federal taxes and sets internal collection
targets. However:
• NRS does not collect all revenue sources.
• Allocation ratios are applied after revenues reach the Budget Office and FAAC.
• Meeting an NRS collection target does not automatically mean Federal Government revenue
targets are met.
This technical sequencing often leads to confusion in public commentary.
2. Capital Expenditure Is Being Under-Executed — But Not Abandoned
There is a narrative that Federal capital projects are not being implemented because MDA capital
releases appear low. This interpretation is incomplete.
Two Components of Federal Capital Expenditure
A. MDA-Funded Capital
• Funded directly from Federal Government cash revenue.
• Dependent on revenue performance.
• Sensitive to oil shortfalls and debt service pressures.
When revenue is constrained, releases slow — lowering visible performance ratios.
B. Multilateral and Project-Tied Loans
• Disbursed directly by development partners.
• Not cash inflows to Federal Government accounts though captured in the budgets.
• Tied to specific infrastructure and social projects.
These projects proceed even when MDA cash releases are limited.
What the Data Shows
2024:
• Total Capital Expenditure: ₦11.59 trillion
• Performance: 84%
2025 (Provisional November):
• ₦11.7 trillion
• Performance: 76%
Conclusion:
Capital projects are ongoing.
Execution continues.
The financing mix differs.
The misunderstanding arises from focusing solely on MDA cash releases rather than total capital
execution.
3. Debt Service Increase Does Not Equal Fiscal Recklessness
Debt service rose above projections in 2024 and 2025.
2024:
• Budgeted: ₦8.56 trillion
• Actual: ₦12.63 trillion
• Overshoot: ₦4 trillion
2025:
• Budgeted: ₦13.12 trillion
• Actual: ₦14.57 trillion
• Overshoot: ₦1.45 trillion
These increases were driven by macroeconomic factors.
A. Naira Depreciation
External debt is denominated in foreign currency. When the Naira depreciates:
• The Naira cost of servicing the same dollar debt rises automatically. This is a valuation effect —
not evidence of new borrowing.
B. Higher Domestic Interest Rates
To stabilize inflation and the currency:
• Monetary policy was tightened.
• Interest rates increased.
• Domestic debt servicing costs rose.
Together, exchange rate and interest rate effects explain the overshoot.
Policy Response
The administration prioritized:
• Debt servicing — to protect sovereign creditworthiness.
• Salaries, wages, and pensions.
• Continued capital implementation.
Crucially, this was done without reverting to monetary financing.
This reflects fiscal discipline under strain — not fiscal collapse.
4. Nigeria’s Debt Is Not Growing Uncontrollably
Public debt has increased in nominal Naira terms, but roughly half of this increase is explained by two
accounting realities:
A. Recognition of ₦30 Trillion Ways and Means
Previously off-book liabilities are now transparently recorded.
This is not new borrowing — it is formal recognition.
B. Exchange Rate Adjustment
When the Naira adjusted:
• The Naira value of external debt rose sharply.
Approximately ₦70 trillion of the nominal increase is attributable to exchange rate valuation.
Thus, much of the increase is accounting and currency-driven — not borrowing-driven.
Debt Sustainability
Debt must be assessed using:
• Debt-to-GDP ratio
• Debt service-to-revenue ratio
• Fiscal deficit trajectory
• Revenue growth trends
With subsidy removal and improved non-oil revenue, structural sustainability is improving.
VI. Revenue Growth: A Critical Signal
Federal Government aggregate revenue:
• 2023: ₦12.48 trillion
• 2024: ₦20.98 trillion
• November 2025: ₦22 trillion
This reflects:
• Improved tax administration
• Greater remittance discipline
• Elimination of leakages
• Stronger non-oil performance
The direction is upward and structural.
VII. Understanding the Transition Strain
The pressures of 2024–2025 reflect the transition from:
Hidden deficits + monetary financing
To:
Greater transparency and market-based financing
Reforms include:
• Subsidy removal
• Exchange rate liberalization
• Ending Ways and Means
• Monetary tightening
• Debt transparency
Such transitions are difficult — but stabilizing over time.
Also note that the 2024 capital budget was executed in 2025 while majority of the 2025 capital budget
plans have been shifted to 2026.
Final Message
Nigeria is not experiencing fiscal collapse.
It is undergoing fiscal correction. The reforms are:
• Structural
• Transparency-driven
• Discipline-enforcing
• Growth-enabling
Misunderstandings arise from:
• Conflating Federation and Federal revenues
• Focusing only on MDA capital releases
• Misinterpreting debt valuation effects
• Ignoring the transparency reset
The evidence shows:
• Revenue is rising.
• Capital projects are ongoing.
• Debt growth is largely transparency and exchange-rate driven.
• Monetary financing has ended.
The administration has chosen long-term sustainability over short-term illusion.
That distinction must guide public discourse going forward.

Shaba Gbenga is a seasoned public relations guru and social media consultant. With over two decades of experience in journalism and media, he started his career with the Ondo State Radiovision Corporation (OSRC) before contributing to notable outlets such as Hope Newspapers, Encomium Magazine, and YES! International Magazine, among others.

